Reviewed by Paul E. Walker

Key Takeaways

  • Relatives count: A sexual relationship with a patient’s parent, spouse, or guardian can lead to an OPMC misconduct charge.
  • Any complaint triggers review: OPMC must investigate every complaint, including one from an angry partner or ex.
  • Keep your distance: Even innocent contact with a patient’s family can be misread.

All physicians are aware that they can never become sexually involved with their patients. However, what about relatives of their patients? The answer is “no”. OPMC will investigate any physician who is reported to have had sexual behavior with members of a patient’s family. This behavior most often occurs when the family member is the parent of a pediatric patient. Remember, the parent is also the guardian of the child, and therefore any inappropriate sexual contact with her might well be punished by OPMC. The extent of the punishment will depend on several factors. Was a child in the room when the contact took place? Was the contact in the office? Does the physician have a history of having sexual contact with a series of parents?

What the Rules Say About Relationships With a Patient’s Relatives

New York’s statutory definitions of what constitutes professional misconduct include conduct that, in the practice of medicine, demonstrates moral unfitness to practice medicine. This can come into play in cases that involve relationships between a provider and a patient’s relative.

The American Medical Association’s Code of Medical Ethics Opinion 9.1.2 identifies the following individuals as key third parties:

  • Spouses
  • Partners
  • Parents
  • Guardians
  • Surrogates

The reason physicians are advised to avoid these relationships is due to the potential exploitation of trust that may be gained through the professional relationship as well as the potential to compromise the care of the patient.

For an example of how these situations can unfold, please see our post on sexual misconduct by a pediatrician with the mothers of his patients.

Why These Relationships Put Your License at Risk

You should not think that you will never be discovered. If you think about it, you will understand that romantic relationships sometimes end with one party being very angry. Since your medical license is so important to you, it is the perfect place to attack if someone wishes to inflict the maximum damage on you. Also, please note that it might not be a jilted parent who contacts OPMC; it might well be a very angry spouse or ex-spouse who would like to savor revenge.

Under Public Health Law § 230(10)(a), OPMC is required to investigate every complaint received, regardless of who the complainant is.

When OPMC investigates issues such as these, they obtain their initial knowledge from the person who files the complaint. That person will probably turn over to OPMC any and all incriminating evidence that is available. This will include all emails, with photos if they exist, text messages, tape recordings, letters, presents given by you, etc. This evidence will be impossible to refute, and if you try to do so at an interview, OPMC will brand you as a liar. Things will not go well for you from that point on.

So, please keep your distance from your patients and their families. Even seemingly innocent contacts might be interpreted as being an attempt to lure someone into an inappropriate relationship. You do not want OPMC investigating you regarding these issues. The mere possibility that you will be brought up on charges will be enough to give you an enormous amount of stress and could endanger your own family situation, as your spouse will no doubt look at you with a skeptical eye. You really do not need any of this in your life.

Contact an Experienced New York Health Care Professional Defense Lawyer

If you are facing allegations of misconduct as a medical professional in New York, it is imperative to connect with an experienced attorney as soon as possible. At Walker Medical Law, we understand how overwhelming these matters can be, especially when your career is on the line. When you need help, do not hesitate to contact our firm today to learn how we can represent you.